I need to do some navel gazing this morning. It doesn’t offer much in the way of spectator sport but for the gazer, it is therapeutic. Reading this might be about as exciting as watching someone study a road map. Still the person engaged can collect and correlate useful information that would be unavailable otherwise. Navel gazing requires me to internalize, to mediate with myself, to weight what might come next, simulate other possibilities. Often it revisits old ideas to see if they have shifted their feet. Gazing can simply beg questions; if-then or, either-or. Sometimes all I need is to reframe a question and clarity emerges out of the murk.
The current social climate (politics & religion) is uncomfortable if not disheartening but like the weather, I’m stuck with it. A little navel gazing can’t hurt. I’ve heard it said, a lawyer who defends himself has a fool for a client. Trying to analyze one’s own psyche would seem the same but I like to think my navel gazing is more like random shuffling of my ducks rather than trying to get them lined up.
I have spent many, many hours reading, studying, discussing and rethinking why it is, how it is that people believe and behave as they do. We (humans) are intelligent and resourceful, we use conscious intellect to theorize and invent both gadgets and schemes to serve our every whim. But we haven’t made the leap yet, the one where emotional bias concedes to rules of reason. Tribal instinct and self-indulgence continue to drive human/human relations. E.O. Wilson said it best; with a great metaphor; he calls us “. . .an evolutionary chimera picking up things from every age without fully transitioning out of any one era. That's why we are a complicated mix of paleolithic emotions, medieval leftovers like banks and religion, and now the latest addition: God-like technology.” Mankind has mastered interplanetary travel yet lacks the insight, certainly lacks the will to mend his own inhumanity. Imagine a family with a new, smart television. They set it up on its stand, hardwire the TV to a solar panel and cut off the power cord. Then they use the cut-off cord to strangle strangers who come to the door.
Nobody wants to believe such stuff so we believe what makes us feel good. Denial and confabulation (another great word) allow people to justify horrible behavior. Rulers, leaders, whatever the culture or nationality, they talk trash in the moment but like Gilgamesh, they think if they get it right they can be Gods; and Gods don’t have to answer to anybody, ever. Wouldn’t that be a hoot; where do I sign up?
Collectively, we are addicted to comfort and convenience (allowed to survive) so we do what is required to maintain status quo, like bees in the hive. Like those bees, we are a super-social species, we need each other. But we are also super-creative, unlike the bees. We can’t get by on instinct alone, have always needed a backstory that gives life meaning and purpose. When language was relatively new, Myth (Human-story) was created that supported and validated a particular social order. We still require myth, it is where you look for a moral measure to gauge how you are doing. From Zeus to Jesus, myth has given us a blueprint for what is acceptable, right and wrong, what we should aspire to and who we can safely emulate.
E.O. Wilson is right there with Crazy Horse and MLK Jr. in my own personal mythology. Most of my countrymen would choose to emulate Wayne La Pierre or a Confederate general who lost at war but endures in the myth. My vision of what makes a worthy purpose is out of sync with what is popular and prideful but it is mine just the same. Keeping with Wilson, when time was kept on the calendar and twenty miles was still a long way, religion served a worthy purpose. It created infrastructure for an extended community where strangers could identify with each other and serve the greater good. In the new century, it has become little more than another power seeking, political ideology where Jesus would be crucified for defending his right to carry a dagger and a sword.
I am not complaining. A thousand years ago, anywhere you look on the planet, life was bleak and suffering was the norm. The human experience has improved dramatically, universally. It is hard to imagine the life and times of a medieval commoner. Thinking about a return to the good old days, when America was great; think again. I may not like the President (I don’t) and I may think our legal system is corrupt (it is) and when conservatives tell me that I am naive (I already knew that) I let it go and when I tell them they have a blind spot in their moral fabric (and they do) they deny, deny, deny. I give thanks for living in the present. The good old days weren’t all that good; what seemed so good was that we were young.
Monday, September 28, 2020
GREAT METAPHOR: DAY 194
Wednesday, September 23, 2020
OMSISCIENT 'WE': DAY 189
When we learn better, we will know better. Then, knowing better, we can do better. But what will we do in the meantime? That is what I would allude to as the omniscient “We”. “We” may be neither all knowing nor all seeing but it presumes an all-inclusive, universal consensus as to who we are and who we are not. I hate it when people use “We” indiscriminately. Just who is included in this “We”? There was a time when I stopped using the word, “we” altogether. I might have said, “Those of us . . .” followed by a qualifier: “who believe in love at first sight. . .” Without naming names or limiting the scope of possibility, I have singled out a subgroup of humans (not the omniscient we) by something shared in particular. If my little hangup seems benign or trivial then so be it, but I hate it (strong word) when conversation/discussion gets lost in a maze of vague generalities. It is quite possible, even unavoidable at times to think there is consensus when in fact there is no way to know. We, you and I, we can agree that, “doing the right thing.” is a good thing. But the “Right Thing” here depends on a predetermined, moral construct. Like software on the computer, morals are downloaded over time and subject to necessary updates. That part of computer function goes on without the operator’s permission. Humans do not get to chose what makes right or wrong either. At some point the subconscious informs the conscious, what is right and what is wrong. Still, the conscious human would rather choose than be informed so it dances with its new partner until a feeling of compatibility is achieved.
I don’t like the omniscient “We”. I associate with a group of people who like to dig in philosophical holes, discuss and debate every alternative. When the going heats up and you have trouble getting a word in, it is easy to shortcut the process with vague generalities. I’ve never been in a hurry to conclude a discussion. It is after all about the journey; at least for me. So when I start hearing the omniscient “We”, rather than interrupt their focus with my distraction I disengage, cat nap, get a new cup of coffee. “What can ‘we’ do? Why don’t ‘we’? ‘We’ have never. . .” on and on. If it is about the ancient Greeks I can frame that in my mind, the Japanese in WW2, I can frame that as well. Sometimes I just need to let it go, understand that my perspective isn’t necessary. Call it smoke on the water. It is a little more civil than pee in the wind. I can speak for me and that’s about as far as my ego needs be fed.
Sunday, September 20, 2020
STRANGER THAN FICTION: DAY 186
I have been telling and retelling this story for so long I can’t be sure if I lived it or if it lived me. Truth can be stranger than fiction for sure and fiction can reveal truths that never happened at all. StoryTellers have been exploring that foggy never-land for as long as there has been story.
In my upstairs bedroom, in our old, clapboard farmhouse on Blue Ridge, it got unbearably hot. So I would take a sheet and pillow down under the locust trees in our front yard, to an Adirondack lawn chair my dad had made from scrap boards. I slept soundly, stirring occasionally to whining tires on the Ridge or the wail of a steam whistle down on the K.C. Southern line. One pitch dark night I woke up to a bright light shining down through the treetops. A voice called down, “LeRoy, LeRoy, are you down there?” That was when I went by my middle name. The light was too bright and the dark was too dark, I couldn’t see a thing. “LeRoy, wake up!” I mumbled something and squinted my eyes. “LeRoy, when you were born you were left here on Earth by mistake. You are not one of them.” I understood what the voice had said but too muddled to reply, I just sat there. “We have missed you. It is time for you to come home with us so we can all be together again.”
I thought about Superman, come to earth from another planet, adopted by good people. Could it be? I didn’t have any super powers but there have been many times when I felt like an alien. I asked how I would get up to them and the voice came back, “We will throw down a ladder.” Just then, as I stood up, the porch light came on. My mom called out; “Is everything alright out here?” I said that it was. She turned off the light and went back inside. The bright light and the voice, they were gone. That hot summer night was enough to sprout the seed, to beg the question: am I an alien? I always sensed I was different; had I been left here by mistake?
It is a recurring dream, not too often but enough, enough to keep begging the question. “Was I left behind by mistake?” If I could phone home like E.T. I wold still be dialing. I wondered if my search party would ever come back. I still wonder. Seventy earth years later, I wonder. I have acclimated to Earth and human culture, not that it fits like a glove but I manage. People get transplanted erroneously all the time here and they manage. The ugly duckling outgrew its paradox, reunited with other longneck swans, a happy ending. But I never outgrew the ‘Human’ look.
In my lifetime, through 14 presidents, through major wars and undeclared hostilities, through Jim Crow, through unmitigated nationalism, through millions of innocent victims, untold crimes against humanity; occasionally something good unfolds. They finally let women vote and fatherhood is no longer license to beat your family. But women are still exploited openly and domestic abuse runs unchecked just under the radar.
In my lifetime, technology has made the leap from a flathead Ford V8 to soft landings on Mars, from aspirin to laser surgery. One would think, with evolved brain power, we would naturally become better people. But as we employ better physics and chemistry, every generation must reinvent the wheel of human interactions, over and again. I am feeling alien, with no recourse. We are stuck in a repeating cycle of arrested development. Civilization is bogged down if not stuck with the emotional balance and poise of a 3 year-old. Poets and peaceful souls, they babble platitudes and proverbs as if someone were taking it to heart. Their wisdom falls on anxious ears but with every important decision, the petulant 3 year-old is called in to prevail. All it lacks is experience and reason, no empathy only apathy, no patience only distain.
As wonderful as it seems, the curse of intellect and reason is that they only comprehend and recommend. At the end of the conversation, a self righteous 3 year-old has to decide. I am feeling alien to this planet and its people. When I go to the bank I drive by the old place. The old, clapboard house is gone with a modern one story in its place. The old trees have given way to new trees. Still, every time, I note the spot where, on hot summer nights, the Adirondack chair used to cradle me and the question begs itself again. “LeRoy, are you there?”