It occurs to me on a regular basis that well written lines from popular songs come to mind when they parallel the experience I am having. I don’t think I am unique in that way but then nobody I know brings it up in conversation either. I belong to a coffee group of 5 that meets twice a week and if you try to rank order us by education and accomplishment I would probably score lowest in the group. I don’t know if they would agree but then our agenda doesn’t seem to dip that deep into our collective experience. This morning while the conversation centered on their pet dogs and cats I was contemplating a Bob Dylan line from 1975 (Buckets Of Rain) that tells us, “Little red wagon, little red bike: I ain’t no monkey but I know what I like.” From the first to the last note the song is a profound statement on human nature. The 70’s were turbulent and Dylan’s creative, drug fueled imagination made him rich. By the end of the 70’s I had managed graduate school and made my leap into parenthood and a career in education. I missed out on the drugs and the riches but I was no monkey, I knew what I liked and life was good. But life has always been good, that’s the point.
Flash-Back to my upbringing and my mother’s nurture: She never missed a chance to remind me of my good fortune with this admonishment, “There but for the Grace of God go I.” Then she would draw me into that blessing with, “and you too.” In my life I have abandoned her religion but not her righteous compass. Certainly the world holds us responsible for what we’ve become but we didn’t get there by ourselves. What I took from that cautionary wisdom was that I may exercise some influence but I certainly do not control my own destiny, I don't believe that anybody sets out to be a failure and that no decision can be judged good or bad until after it has run its course. Her purpose was the virtue of humility and to that end she made her point. All I can do is to weigh and measure the moment and do my best. That would acknowledge thousands of strangers fingerprints that are all over everything I have ever done. Naturally I must treat my decisions as crucial to my fate but at the end of the day I default back to my mother’s humble disposition and to John Donne who wrote; No man is an island. Don’t ask for whom the bell tolls, it tolls for thee.
This morning at coffee none of us bothered to mention how fortunate we all are to have lived so long and so well. I felt the legacy of White Privilege, how without it the odds would have been overpowering that I would have never seen the inside of a university library. I can’t speak for my coffee-mates but likewise, I question they would have risen to their levels of professional achievement if they had been persons of color. It confirms the notion that the three most important decisions you will ever make are; choosing your parents, choosing the year and the location of your birth. One bad choice and consider how disappointing and dismal this life could have been.
On the way home from coffee I stopped at Trader Joe’s, a small but trendy grocery store where the parking lot is full of German cars and customers are amazingly free of tattoos. I don’t think people dress up to go to Trader Joe’s, that must be how they dress all the time. Neither do I know for sure if they ever think about White Privilege but for the most part they have all been immersed in it for a long time; not many Blacks or Tans pushing carts through the isles. Still, birds of a feather flock together and I seem to fit in. Maybe I am affluent (wealthy) after all; I don’t have to check the price before I decide to buy the shredded parmesan cheese or a bottle of Carmenere wine. Carmenere is a Chilean red wine that pops in the front of your mouth and sinus, unlike the traditional favorite Cabernet Sauvignon with heavy tannins that settle in the back of the mouth and throat. I like the Carmenere but not the Cabernet. Talking with the lady in charge of the wine department she sensed I knew more about wine than what color I was looking for. She agreed the Cab was overrated and my preference was spot on; not that I’m a wine snob just more like Dylan’s observation, “I’m no monkey but I know what I like”. Still, my 24 year-old pickup truck in the parking lot will never be mistaken for an expensive German car.
There is no virtue, none at all in being affluent (wealthy). It provides purchasing power but you can’t buy virtue. I shop at Trader Joe’s once or twice a month but I shop often at a Walmart Superstore. I shop there because I get more for less and I identify with young parents who have more kids than they can afford and with old invalids in self propelled wheel chairs. My mother did not waste words on me; there but for the Grace of random chance and good karma go I. That could be me or I could be one of them, either way. But you cannot ignore the obvious; Walmart is not Trader Joe’s. For those who think they deserve better than Walmart because they are affluent or educated I don’t think anybody deserves anything. You get what you get and live with it. Ironically these disposable, invisible people who struggle to survive, who love their children but cannot provide, who give up easily because nothing has ever worked and because bad habits are truly hard to break; I identify with them; it could have been me. Every time I fell I landed softly and every time I got back up someone gave me a second chance. Good fortune is unmerited benefit that cannot be anticipated and I’ve had my share.
If I were a practicing Christian I would default to the Sermon on the Mount where Jesus said, “He makes the sun rise on the evil and the good and he sends rain on the just and the unjust. . .' Some would say that good luck is simply the intersection of preparation and opportunity but that falls short of those thousands of stranger’s fingerprints all over everything you’ve ever done. Keep it simple, “Do unto others” and “fix what you fu*k up.”
Sing it again Bob:
I've been meek
And hard like an oak
I've seen pretty people disappear like smoke
Friends will arrive, friends will disappear
If you want me
Honey baby, I'll be here
Flash-Back to my upbringing and my mother’s nurture: She never missed a chance to remind me of my good fortune with this admonishment, “There but for the Grace of God go I.” Then she would draw me into that blessing with, “and you too.” In my life I have abandoned her religion but not her righteous compass. Certainly the world holds us responsible for what we’ve become but we didn’t get there by ourselves. What I took from that cautionary wisdom was that I may exercise some influence but I certainly do not control my own destiny, I don't believe that anybody sets out to be a failure and that no decision can be judged good or bad until after it has run its course. Her purpose was the virtue of humility and to that end she made her point. All I can do is to weigh and measure the moment and do my best. That would acknowledge thousands of strangers fingerprints that are all over everything I have ever done. Naturally I must treat my decisions as crucial to my fate but at the end of the day I default back to my mother’s humble disposition and to John Donne who wrote; No man is an island. Don’t ask for whom the bell tolls, it tolls for thee.
This morning at coffee none of us bothered to mention how fortunate we all are to have lived so long and so well. I felt the legacy of White Privilege, how without it the odds would have been overpowering that I would have never seen the inside of a university library. I can’t speak for my coffee-mates but likewise, I question they would have risen to their levels of professional achievement if they had been persons of color. It confirms the notion that the three most important decisions you will ever make are; choosing your parents, choosing the year and the location of your birth. One bad choice and consider how disappointing and dismal this life could have been.
On the way home from coffee I stopped at Trader Joe’s, a small but trendy grocery store where the parking lot is full of German cars and customers are amazingly free of tattoos. I don’t think people dress up to go to Trader Joe’s, that must be how they dress all the time. Neither do I know for sure if they ever think about White Privilege but for the most part they have all been immersed in it for a long time; not many Blacks or Tans pushing carts through the isles. Still, birds of a feather flock together and I seem to fit in. Maybe I am affluent (wealthy) after all; I don’t have to check the price before I decide to buy the shredded parmesan cheese or a bottle of Carmenere wine. Carmenere is a Chilean red wine that pops in the front of your mouth and sinus, unlike the traditional favorite Cabernet Sauvignon with heavy tannins that settle in the back of the mouth and throat. I like the Carmenere but not the Cabernet. Talking with the lady in charge of the wine department she sensed I knew more about wine than what color I was looking for. She agreed the Cab was overrated and my preference was spot on; not that I’m a wine snob just more like Dylan’s observation, “I’m no monkey but I know what I like”. Still, my 24 year-old pickup truck in the parking lot will never be mistaken for an expensive German car.
There is no virtue, none at all in being affluent (wealthy). It provides purchasing power but you can’t buy virtue. I shop at Trader Joe’s once or twice a month but I shop often at a Walmart Superstore. I shop there because I get more for less and I identify with young parents who have more kids than they can afford and with old invalids in self propelled wheel chairs. My mother did not waste words on me; there but for the Grace of random chance and good karma go I. That could be me or I could be one of them, either way. But you cannot ignore the obvious; Walmart is not Trader Joe’s. For those who think they deserve better than Walmart because they are affluent or educated I don’t think anybody deserves anything. You get what you get and live with it. Ironically these disposable, invisible people who struggle to survive, who love their children but cannot provide, who give up easily because nothing has ever worked and because bad habits are truly hard to break; I identify with them; it could have been me. Every time I fell I landed softly and every time I got back up someone gave me a second chance. Good fortune is unmerited benefit that cannot be anticipated and I’ve had my share.
If I were a practicing Christian I would default to the Sermon on the Mount where Jesus said, “He makes the sun rise on the evil and the good and he sends rain on the just and the unjust. . .' Some would say that good luck is simply the intersection of preparation and opportunity but that falls short of those thousands of stranger’s fingerprints all over everything you’ve ever done. Keep it simple, “Do unto others” and “fix what you fu*k up.”
Sing it again Bob:
I've been meek
And hard like an oak
I've seen pretty people disappear like smoke
Friends will arrive, friends will disappear
If you want me
Honey baby, I'll be here